Is Your Church’s Finance Office Actually Slowing Down Ministry?

Is Your Church's Finance Office Actually Slowing Down Ministry?

One of the things I see all the time in churches is that the finance office becomes the gatekeeper to all financial information. And I'm not just talking about small churches.

I was recently talking with a church doing around $10 million a year. Their ministry leaders were getting budget versus actual reports from their accountant about 10 days into the following month, and that was essentially the financial information they had available. If they wanted to know how much money they had left to spend, they had to ask somebody. If they needed to understand why something had changed in their budget, they had to wait for the finance office to explain it.

I think this is incredibly common in churches of almost every size, and I think it's creating a bigger problem than we realize. We've built financial systems that are designed to maintain control over financial information rather than equip the people responsible for leading ministry.

Because here's what I believe: Finance is a leadership function, not just an administrative function.

Finance Doesn't Set the Vision, but It Does Determine the Pace

This is something I say all the time. Finance doesn't set the vision, but it does determine the pace at which we can accomplish that vision. And if that's true, every leader in our organization needs some understanding of the financial resources available to them.

Think about your youth pastor. That person is in the trenches of youth ministry every week. They know what's happening with students, what opportunities are coming up, and what resources are needed to accomplish what God has called them to do. Your finance person probably doesn't understand those things at nearly the same level, and that's okay. They have different responsibilities.

The finance team's job should be to provide accurate information, identify financial concerns, and help ministry leaders understand the resources available to them. But the people actually leading those ministries should be involved in making decisions about how those resources are used.

When we keep all of the financial information centralized in the finance office, we're asking ministry leaders to accomplish something without giving them the information they need to lead. And then we wonder why they're constantly asking for permission or why every financial decision seems to end up on the executive pastor's desk.

That's not just inefficient. I think it can actually hinder ministry.

Give Your Ministry Leaders Access to Their Numbers

I'm a huge proponent of pushing financial stewardship down through every level of the organization. And one of the easiest ways to start doing that is through real-time financial reporting.

Give your department leaders a dashboard they can access whenever they need it. Or at least give them reports frequently enough that they're making decisions based on what's happening now rather than what happened six weeks ago.

Now, are those numbers going to be perfectly reconciled every single day? Probably not. And that's okay, as long as everybody understands that they're looking at preliminary information. I like giving ministry leaders access to reporting that provides roughly 90–95% of the picture in real time. The finance team still needs to complete the monthly close, reconcile everything, and produce accurate financial statements. But ministry shouldn't have to come to a stop while everyone waits for that process.

And here's something interesting I've noticed when we've implemented this with churches. It actually helps the finance team produce better information.

All of a sudden, department leaders start paying attention to what's hitting their budgets. They'll come back and say, "Hey, that expense shouldn't be in my department. That belongs to somebody else."

I used to get a kick out of watching staff members fight over whose budget an expense belonged to. But you know what that told me? They were actually looking at their financial reports! They cared about their budgets because they cared about accomplishing their ministries.

And they were catching coding mistakes that the accounting team might not have recognized. After all, the accountant doesn't necessarily know whether a particular purchase was supposed to come out of the youth budget or children's ministry. But the ministry leaders do.

So now we've removed a bottleneck, given our leaders better information, and helped our finance team produce more accurate reports. That's a win for everybody.

Give Your Leaders Boundaries, Not a Playbook

But giving ministry leaders access to their financial information is only half the equation. We also have to give them the authority to make decisions within appropriate boundaries.

I was talking with a church recently that was building its departmental budgets at the line-item level. They were determining exactly how much the youth ministry would spend on supplies, contract labor, camps, and every other category throughout the year.

Now, I don't have a problem with doing that work to determine how much a ministry needs. In fact, I think it's valuable. But once we've done that exercise and determined that youth ministry needs $12,000 for the year, why not give the youth pastor that budget and let them lead within it?

I grew up playing football and spent several years coaching it. In football, you call a play, and everybody has a very specific assignment. The quarterback does one thing, the running back does another, and the receiver runs a particular route. It's incredibly structured.

But think about basketball. There's still a strategy, there are rules, and there are boundaries. But the players have freedom to make decisions based on what's happening on the court. They don't have to stop and ask the coach for permission every time an opportunity presents itself.

I think we need to approach ministry budgets more like that. We establish the boundaries, communicate the expectations, and let our leaders operate within those parameters.

Because what your youth pastor expected to happen in January may look completely different by July. An unexpected ministry opportunity might come up. Maybe something they planned doesn't work, or there's a new need they couldn't have anticipated when the budget was built.

If we've predetermined exactly how every dollar has to be spent, we've limited their ability to respond. And I think we can unintentionally create a financial system that works against the very ministry we're trying to support.

Accountability Should Develop Leaders, Not Restrict Them

Now, this doesn't mean that if we give somebody a $12,000 budget, they have $12,000 guaranteed to spend. That's something I always tried to communicate clearly to my staff when I was serving as an executive pastor.

A budget is our best estimate of the resources we believe we'll have available to accomplish the ministry we've planned. Sometimes giving doesn't perform the way we expected. Sometimes unexpected expenses come up. And sometimes we have to make adjustments.

But those situations should become opportunities to coach our leaders rather than reasons to take away their authority.

I'm a big believer in allowing what I call bike accidents. When you're teaching your kid to ride a bike, you have to let them fall sometimes. That's how they learn. But you're not going to let them ride off the curb into oncoming traffic.

There's a difference between allowing someone to make a mistake they can learn from and allowing them to make a decision that could create catastrophic consequences. We need to understand where those boundaries are, and we need to create room for our leaders to grow within them.

That's where I think the finance team has an incredible opportunity. Instead of being the people who always have to say no, they can become the people who help ministry leaders understand their resources and make better decisions.

And that doesn't require turning every ministry leader into an accountant.

When I was serving as an executive pastor, we had limitations in our reporting software that made it difficult to display monthly budgets. So we developed a simple way to help our staff understand whether they were on track. We'd show what percentage of the year had passed alongside what percentage of their budget they'd spent.

If we were 25% of the way through the year, we'd generally want those numbers to be reasonably close, allowing for planned seasonal expenses. It wasn't a complete financial analysis, but it was simple enough for someone without a financial background to understand.

And that's what good financial reporting should do. It should make financial stewardship accessible to the people responsible for leading ministry.

Financial Stewardship Belongs Throughout the Church

One of the objections I hear when talking about giving ministry leaders greater access to financial information is that churches aren't sure they can trust their staff with it.

And that's something I think we need to wrestle with.

If we're trusting these people to pastor people, care for them, and steward their hearts, why are we so hesitant to trust them with financial information?

I believe God cares a whole lot more about people than He does about money. And yet we sometimes give ministry leaders enormous responsibility for the spiritual care of others while withholding the information they need to make basic financial decisions.

Obviously, we need appropriate confidentiality, accountability, and financial controls. But those things shouldn't keep us from equipping the people we've entrusted with leadership.

Financial stewardship shouldn't be confined to the finance office. It should be developed throughout the organization.

When we begin to think about finances that way, it changes the kind of systems we build, the information we provide, and the authority we're willing to entrust to our leaders.

Our job is to create financial systems that empower people to accomplish the ministry God has called them to do, not systems they constantly have to work around.

Because finance doesn't set the vision. But it absolutely influences how effectively we can move that vision forward.

Previous
Previous

Your Church Can Have Perfect Books and Still Be Financially Blind